So the final lists I got were:

roslinpl - 100
conteaza - 1100 - list was 1200 but had some dupes
Candystripes - 842
TRICHED - 2965

sinecoin - said only half his list had domain names.  looks like a quick copy and paste from a wiki.  I don't trust the quality and therefore didn't request the actual list.

All of the other lists were good quality.  TRICHED's list was huge but most of the sites were still relevant.

Paid 1.5 BTC total.  5007 URLs = 0.000299581 BTC each.  Proportional payments:

roslinpl - 0.03 BTC to 19tBQCj71a2MCem23xjFgzNvKhcxjgCHwa - https://blockchain.info/tx/463afeedf6c46b25f46b0cbae1bbbae03268812a1ae155236ad9f251e77b3807
conteaza - 0.33 BTC to 15xcKtBDjVU67FkAzfXYzZfPHQ18Mbdy7T - https://blockchain.info/tx/4078b1845ad3fbd8385343860be0312f9f1074510f67fc2a0a2cc9af874edf06
Candystripes - 0.25 BTC to 1CandyPE2zp8TQ55BA9gUP4qgVHzzPdDQ7 - https://blockchain.info/tx/2e3160784c090a2f6b175b2a18597b9433d317d7c1cfc8516a0943d0562f626d
TRICHED - 0.89 BTC to 16kXabXYDdNK6VhV8wKnh6fWYmLEazpJRE - https://blockchain.info/tx/da49eee85386263cf0287b6ae2e26294f00937faca185d5f628e271bc9c1f621

And if anyone is going to complain about the payments not matching the OP (even though I added 0.5 BTC and divided up the payments as fairly as possible), realize that if I'd stuck to the OP the only person eligible would be Gianluca95 since he was the first to claim the job, and no one else would have gotten anything.  Adjusting the payments to match the situation was the best option.