While you do make well-reasoned points, Dooglus has the right and justification to provide his assessment of not only your trust level, but also other members' trust level. Whether Dooglus is right or wrong, this forum relies on a trust system that is crucial given Bitcoin's anonymity and value. Dooglus can exercise his right to provide a trust rating, and given his immense contribution to the Bitcoin community, his opinions have meaning.  

In my opinion, Dooglus has enormous credibility given he probably has seen a wide range of dishonest behavior in the Bitcoin community.