I also like the banner and think that the gold was a good change, the only other thing that I would say is the icons. I do not believe that moocraft is our official Minecraft server anymore (am I right on this?), so maybe change that Icon to one for the pixlemon server or another popular server that we have. But other than that I really like it, good work!
Icon can be changed. I took these from the HYPER website, where Moocraft is still the main site being shown off...
Also, I should have the site back up and running today. Whatever I did completely screwed the server, so it's taking a complete reformat and starting over. Luckily, I took backups. Just gotta hope they aren't out of date or anything.