Search content
Sort by

Showing 16 of 16 results by Haputa
Post
Topic
Board Electrum
Re: How to fix low fee issue
by
Haputa
on 04/01/2018, 08:02:20 UTC
I am happy to say that the transaction has been unstuck, using the CPFP option in Electrum. I used http://bitcoinfees.earn.com/ to find a fee that would take about 15 hours, and it did that almost to the minute.

Thanks to everyone who has replied and helped me in the proces!

-Haputa
Post
Topic
Board Electrum
Re: How to fix low fee issue
by
Haputa
on 03/01/2018, 17:31:42 UTC
1) If I read correctly, RBF is an option I can activate for future transactions? I will definitely look into this and making sure I have a high enough fee for any of my future transactions. I work with Electrum, not with Mycelium. When I right-click on the unconfirmed transaction, I don't see the 'selecting increase fee' option.
Yup. You can't increase the fees on the transactions that you have already broadcasted. If you have the replace by fee option selected, you can create another transaction with a much higher fee to "replace" the current transaction that is in the mempool.

2) I am the receiver of the funds, but on the Kraken account. When I right click on the unconfirmed transaction in Electrum, I do see the 'Child Pays For Parent' option, though. Should I try this out?
Sure. Child pay for parents allows for child transaction (the transaction you are creating) to help to incentivise the miners to get the whole chain of transaction confirmed. This method will work as long as the transaction has an output to an address that you control. This does include a hefty fee however, since you are also effectively creating a new transaction.

Thanks for your reply, Ranochigo!

So for the CPFP option, could I assume the fee gets doubled? Or what would be an effective fee to unstuck the transaction?

Edit: To clarify, I mean to ask if a sufficient fee would get doubled. Not the original fee.
Post
Topic
Board Electrum
Re: How to fix low fee issue
by
Haputa
on 03/01/2018, 15:42:16 UTC
There are a couple of ways you can do this. This is how I'd do it in Electrum:

1) Replace by fee - In electrum there's the ability to go to "If fee is too low" or "Always" from Fee preferences in Tools. This would've then let you select 'Replacable' to allowed you to later on replace the fee of your existing transaction. Could you check if Mycelium allows this feature? I'm not sure since I haven't used that wallet. I believe I was able to do this in electrum by right clicking on the unconfirmed transaction -> selecting increase fee --> then setting a higher fee or using electrum's dynamic fee that was already set.

2) This is possible now if you're receiving the funds - Child-pays-for-parent  - In the 'History' section right click on the transaction that is unconfirmed and then selected Child pays for parent -> increase the fee this time to a suitable fee (calculate it from here: https://bitcoinfees.earn.com/) -> Sign and broadcast the transaction.

3) By using a transaction accelerator like confirmtx, viabtc's tx accelerator or antpools tx accelerator. I've accelerated your transaction on confirmtx and antpool's accelerator. It might get confirmed in upcoming blocks when they include your tx in their block that is mined. If you can't wait for this option to have your tx confirmed, follow option 2 if you're receiving the funds.

Edit: Updated post after confirmation.

Hello xdrpx and thanks for your reply!

1) If I read correctly, RBF is an option I can activate for future transactions? I will definitely look into this and making sure I have a high enough fee for any of my future transactions. I work with Electrum, not with Mycelium. When I right-click on the unconfirmed transaction, I don't see the 'selecting increase fee' option.

2) I am the receiver of the funds, but on the Kraken account. When I right click on the unconfirmed transaction in Electrum, I do see the 'Child Pays For Parent' option, though. Should I try this out?

3) Thank you for accelerating my transaction. I have tried so myself through ViaBTC, but could never get through. I did read somewhere that this form of 'bumping' is overcrowded a lot these days. I could wait a bit to see if this works for me, though.

Thanks again for helping me here!
Post
Topic
Board Electrum
How to fix low fee issue
by
Haputa
on 03/01/2018, 14:12:30 UTC
Hello,

A few weeks ago I have sent a transaction with Multibit HD to my Kraken account with a very low fee.
Transaction ID: (3bf2e0fdd4a9ad01b83c679f83c247d019ecfa6f18c4fd075978b2c47075200a)

At the time I had no understanding what the fee means, now I realise it was to low and the transaction got stuck because of it. I have since then imported my Multibit wallet to Electrum and Electrum correctly states the transaction as 'Low fee'.

What is the best way to get this transaction unstuck now? Bumping through viabtc.com doens't seem to work these days.

I would very much appreciate any help, since I have been struggeling with this one for quite a while already.


Kind regards,
Haputa
Post
Topic
Board Electrum
Re: Signing issue Electrum
by
Haputa
on 31/12/2017, 16:18:57 UTC
bump
Post
Topic
Board Electrum
Re: Signing issue Electrum
by
Haputa
on 27/12/2017, 12:58:36 UTC
So you've already created and broadcasted this transaction :https://blockchain.info/tx/3bf2e0fdd4a9ad01b83c679f83c247d019ecfa6f18c4fd075978b2c47075200a but it is unconfirmed due to low fees.

Yes, we're trying to double spend the transaction (with higher fees) now to get it unstuck.
Post
Topic
Board Electrum
Re: Signing issue Electrum
by
Haputa
on 23/12/2017, 10:59:05 UTC
you do not need to create a file! simply open your Electrum, and from the menu select Tools > Load transaction > From text
and then just paste the raw unsigned transaction there.

i'm not sure why it is showing 'Status: Signed', that is really strange and it shouldn't do that.

but in any case Electrum will not recognize nor sign this raw unsigned transaction because your ScriptSig field is empty and Electrum needs to know which private key to use for signing the transaction.

Code:
0100000001d45343bf472dcb8ca243daccf39b49399065e52bc310068641609cb48f24433c000000001901ff16fd00af6c62d8114d4a4a1d5b9d5d655ca3cf6b3b9ba1000000000240c7130d000000001976a914ed7de5536a51adb2ffa6a8550754b031d73fe19e88ac1ef161000000000017a91461b10fa7361e7e62285a03532263790541f563d58700000000

use at your own risk.

Thanks for your reply, pooya87!

I have tried to sign from text, but also here it says Status: Signed.

Just for more info, it also says:
Size: 142 bytes
Fee: unknown
Inputs (1)
and has unknown after the input data
The first output is highlighted yellow.

Hope this tells you a bit more of what's going wrong here.

Edit: also would like to add that this tx was created from MultiBitHD to Kraken, before switching to Electrum during the resolving proces of the stuck tx.
Post
Topic
Board Electrum
Signing issue Electrum
by
Haputa
on 22/12/2017, 12:08:34 UTC
Hi there,

I am trying to resolve a stuck transaction through the double spend method, guided by mocacinno in his help thread (https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1943939.160).

He has created a transaction for me with a higher fee that should replace the old transaction when I sign and broadcast it. I am using Electrum to do these last steps, but I am encountering an issue that mocacinno also doesn't know the answer to. I am hoping someone on this subforum could help us find out what we should do differently.

I have created a .txn file with the following data:

Quote
{
    "final": false,
    "complete": false,
    "hex": "0100000001d45343bf472dcb8ca243daccf39b49399065e52bc310068641609cb48f24433c00000 00000ffffffff0240c7130d000000001976a914ed7de5536a51adb2ffa6a8550754b031d73fe19e 88ac1ef161000000000017a91461b10fa7361e7e62285a03532263790541f563d58700000000"
}

In Electrum, I load the transaction, but for some reason it already says 'Status: Signed' and the Sign button is greyed out. Tried both online and offline.

Anyone here knows what's going on, why it says already signed? Any help is very much appreciated!


Kind regards,
Haputa
Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Technical Support
Re: [free] help with your stuck transaction
by
Haputa
on 21/12/2017, 15:54:11 UTC
I do appreciate you want to do this for me, but if you don't mind too much, I would prefer to learn how to do this myself.

If you rather just handle this one for me, around 700sat/byte (1.5mBTC) is what Electrum automatically puts the fee on. This is fine if you think that is what it takes at the moment. Take it from 1Nejxrk4Y9Q2eQ6YTd3hMi46uSnnN4Ghbn. I do see a Sign and Broadcast button when I preview a transaction, so I should be able to handle it from there.

Thanks again.

I'm a big fan of people wanting to learn Smiley
The "problem" is that it's easyer to create a raw, unsigned transaction if you're running a synced node (like i am doing), electrum is perfect for signing transactions, but not so good at doublespending unspent outputs that have already been spent.

If you want to learn the basics, you can download the sourcecode of coinb.in, i've actually written a small post on my blog on it's basic usage a long time ago: http://www.mocacinno.com/blog/create-sign-broadcast-transactions-using-coinb/
I wouldn't use coinb.in to sign the transaction tough (so you don't need to follow the complete article).

If you succeeded in creating a double spending tx using coinb.in, please post the unsigned transaction in this thread and i'll review it for you and give you some pointers on how to sign it using electrum Smiley

Alright, I have tried following the tutorial, but getting stuck far too soon already lol. I think I will need some more time to learn slowly and will keep working on it. For now, would you be so kind to create the double spend tx with around 700sat/byte from the 1Nejxrk4Y9Q2eQ6YTd3hMi46uSnnN4Ghbn wallet?

Thanks bud Smiley
Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Technical Support
Re: [free] help with your stuck transaction
by
Haputa
on 21/12/2017, 10:26:29 UTC
A big thanks to HCP for helping me get trough the many requests... Couldn't do this without a little help from time to time  Grin

It looks like this is the only question left open at the moment:

If I understand correctly, I now have to create a new transaction from Electrum. I enter the same address in 'pay to' and the same amount. Then send the transaction and broadcast it? Is that all?
No. Double spending requires that you use the same inputs... If you just create a new transaction without knowing what you're doing, you could spend "different" coins and end up sending 2 payments! Best wait for mocacinno to help! Wink


Good thing I have not taken action yet, cheers for the heads up!

I don't know then what the same inputs means, I thought it would be the address and amount you 'put in', but I'm just a scrub.

I'll create a double spending transaction for you... The only thing i wanted to ask: could you tell me which output value i can take the extra fee from? You're funding 1Nejxrk4Y9Q2eQ6YTd3hMi46uSnnN4Ghbn and 3AbZaaKj4ZVomw4YKTTpraqQYbaesByTpJ, i'll have to reduce one of these outputs to leave room for a bigger fee... It's up to you to pick witch one.

Once you tell me where to take the fee from, i'll create an unsigned transaction, since you moved to electrum, you *should* be able to sign said transaction with your electrum wallet and broadcast it afterwards. It's been a while since i last did this, so i hope it still works, but i don't think it'll be a big problem

I do appreciate you want to do this for me, but if you don't mind too much, I would prefer to learn how to do this myself.

If you rather just handle this one for me, around 700sat/byte (1.5mBTC) is what Electrum automatically puts the fee on. This is fine if you think that is what it takes at the moment. Take it from 1Nejxrk4Y9Q2eQ6YTd3hMi46uSnnN4Ghbn. I do see a Sign and Broadcast button when I preview a transaction, so I should be able to handle it from there.

Thanks again.
Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Technical Support
Re: [free] help with your stuck transaction
by
Haputa
on 20/12/2017, 19:54:20 UTC

If I understand correctly, I now have to create a new transaction from Electrum. I enter the same address in 'pay to' and the same amount. Then send the transaction and broadcast it? Is that all?
No. Double spending requires that you use the same inputs... If you just create a new transaction without knowing what you're doing, you could spend "different" coins and end up sending 2 payments! Best wait for mocacinno to help! Wink


Good thing I have not taken action yet, cheers for the heads up!

I don't know then what the same inputs means, I thought it would be the address and amount you 'put in', but I'm just a scrub.
Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Technical Support
Re: [free] help with your stuck transaction
by
Haputa
on 20/12/2017, 17:47:33 UTC

--snip--
Transaction ID: 3bf2e0fdd4a9ad01b83c679f83c247d019ecfa6f18c4fd075978b2c47075200a
--snip--

Appologies for the lack of intel.

I am both sender (from MultibitHD) and receiver (to Kraken). I have learned so far that the problem is caused due to low fee per byte.

I do hope to settle this transaction within the next few days, any idea what I can do best in this situation? Would waiting a little longer cause a the transaction to be refunded or what would happen if it doesn't get confirmed in the next few days?

Thanks for any help!

Since the receiver is an exchange, this pretty much rules out CPFP, the tx isn't opt-in RBF so that's out of the question to...
Multibit HD is no longer supported, if you move away from multibit HD to electrum (tutorial can be found here: https://multibit.org/blog/2017/07/26/multibit-shutdown.html), you SHOULD be able to follow my wizard on http://www.mocacinno.com/page/feechecker to create, sign and broadcast a transaction double spending the inputs of the unconfirmed transaction using electrum


Already helped me a long way here, thanks again for that. You're doing great work!

I have switched to electrum succesfully. Now I want to do the double spending, but feel uncertain if I'm doing this absolutely correctly. So I will bother you one more time, to make sure not to make any mistakes.

If I understand correctly, I now have to create a new transaction from Electrum. I enter the same address in 'pay to' and the same amount. Then send the transaction and broadcast it? Is that all?
Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Technical Support
Re: [free] help with your stuck transaction
by
Haputa
on 19/12/2017, 21:01:42 UTC

Hi there,

I read that there's not much to bump at the moment, but if you find any way to help out, here's the ID of my stuck transaction:

Transaction ID: 3bf2e0fdd4a9ad01b83c679f83c247d019ecfa6f18c4fd075978b2c47075200a

Would very much appreciate some kind of bump to the chain!

Are you the sender or the receiver, and which kind of wallet software were you using?

Appologies for the lack of intel.

I am both sender (from MultibitHD) and receiver (to Kraken). I have learned so far that the problem is caused due to low fee per byte.

I do hope to settle this transaction within the next few days, any idea what I can do best in this situation? Would waiting a little longer cause a the transaction to be refunded or what would happen if it doesn't get confirmed in the next few days?

Thanks for any help!
Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Technical Support
Re: Transaction stuck for 33+ hrs
by
Haputa
on 19/12/2017, 10:00:37 UTC
Thanks for the info and help. I will keep trying to accelerate and be patient for now.
Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Technical Support
Re: [free] help with your stuck transaction
by
Haputa
on 18/12/2017, 22:49:49 UTC
Hi there,

I read that there's not much to bump at the moment, but if you find any way to help out, here's the ID of my stuck transaction:

Transaction ID: 3bf2e0fdd4a9ad01b83c679f83c247d019ecfa6f18c4fd075978b2c47075200a

Would very much appreciate some kind of bump to the chain!
Post
Topic
Board Bitcoin Technical Support
Transaction stuck for 33+ hrs
by
Haputa
on 18/12/2017, 22:19:22 UTC
Hi all,

First time making a transaction from MultibitHD wallet to Kraken wallet. Shouldn't take this long, right?

Transaction ID: 3bf2e0fdd4a9ad01b83c679f83c247d019ecfa6f18c4fd075978b2c47075200a

ViaBTC submissions beyond limit. Any help appreciated!


Kind regards, Haputa