Thank you OurASIC and all above for bringing community sourced ASICs back to foreground.
The most important thing is having a vision and transform it into real, viable plan. The discussion is already lit up. That's the best way to get there.
We might argue if a company is evil or not when trying to max profit at free market while staying in compliance with law. But that's not the important bit.
The most important question that enables us to forge viable plan: What is our advantage as a community over a "evil" company?
As many of you suggested above, market does apply to a community project same as commercial one. (People wouldn't buy community ASIC when there is better commercial deal.) So, let's see what community can do better than a commercial start-up.
Personally, I think our biggest advantage is being able to take the time to develop as good as it gets. A ASIC commercial company needs to make profit as soon as possible. Their chips could be twice (maybe more) as good, but the capital they use is not their own and expenses on keeping investment grow in time. They have to make some fiat profit fast.
The second big advantage (still my personal opinions) is community funding "as seen on Kickstarter". I would give my money to open community project where I know where my money goes, whats the state of it and the "never done before" goal we share. Where having it stuck as pre-order at some company is scary. My money could be on their way to Bahamas already.
And the third is the brains. A commercial company can offer money to developers, and then throw them away when they done their job. We can offer money too, but on top of that, well ... Companies come and go. ... We as a community are here to stay as long as there is math and some kind of money in the world.
What do you think is our advantage(s) if any?