Well what are the reasons for or against an N reset?
And why would we do this instead of just starting again with a new coin?
I'm not sure why you would even think this a valid strategy. Starting over on N IS making a new coin.
We don't jump to NF=18 for a whole year, so don't start stocking your survival shelter yet. By the time it arrives, YAC will have been on NF=17 for nearly 1/3 of its existence and it will just be "normal". Is NF=17 hard on our GPU's? It is. Is it any different from any NFactor change in the past? No. Every change in NFactor is met with confusion, frustration, and HW errors. This difference is that we have years of understanding now instead of days, or weeks, or months.
We've known for a while that CPU would become competitive to GPUs again at this NFactor, we just need to figure out how to keep the hashrate spread out so that there's no 51% network ownership. We had this situation for a long, lone time with coinmine.pl having >51%, but everyone was okay with it because that's where most of the miners were. During that period, solo mining was difficult because the pool would get most of the blocks and people not on the pool would see orphans. Now, we have someone who has quite the mining capacity, but he's solo-mining, but only during specified hours, leaving the pools with orphans. It's quite possible that this is not even malicious intent (other than likely using computers that aren't his or hers), but just that much hashpower that it dominates the network.