The logical fail of OP & NY regulators lies in the premise that "if something is bad, it needs regulation"
The supporting argument being: "look, something was bad, then regulation came out, it is good now"
This original premise is considered to be the "universal truth", when, in fact it is not.
Because it is considered a "universal truth", they cannot see any other ways to fix it.
For example, they could just leave it alone and market forces will fix it.
REGULATION IS NOT THE ONLY WAY!