20 votes for proposal #1.
I like papa_lazzarou and xulescu's proposals. While proposal #2 is IMO in the long-term interest, I think Monero currently still needs the exposure that it receives here, and I'm unsure what the implications are of moving away from BTCTalk completely at this stage.
I think it's clear at this point we need to rephrase the vote options. If you agree with what I say and vote the other way than I do, it means we read different things in the same options. Maybe have more options to support, like:
1. Stay here completely, for the medium term. Do not use the Monero forum or only use it sparingly.
2. Keep public facing stuff here, private stuff on the Monero forum.
3. Let the market decide - in the meanwhile, there is going to be duplication and overhead to maintain two centres.
4. Start moving to the Monero forum now or immediately after a successful vote, close most threads here, keep the remaining ones as mostly-announcements, finish transition in ~1 month or so.
5. Move to the Monero forum immediately after a successful vote and keep a minimal presence here, or none at all.
My 100 votes would go with (4).