Quote from: Komodozed on Today at 01:51:53 AM

Quote from: Komodozed on May 11, 2020, 10:54:01 PM

Today I read on discord that candidate "wbpxre150" [aka Blackjoker] was banned from taking up his NN in season 4 for something he did a long time ago.

I cast 1000000 VOTE2020 towards wbpxre150 which are void now, and obviously do not count towards the election result for season 4.

This is very unfair to me as a community member and active participant in the season 4 NN election.

If wbpxre150 was not eligible to take up a winning position, why was he allowed to run in the election at all?

Why was wbpxre150's NN proposal not banned BEFORE the election started?

I would like to have my 1M VOTE2020 returned to my original address so I can participate in the season 4 election.

I did not do anything wrong, I know nothing about what wbpxre150 did until today, I have been greatly disadvantaged, my 1M VOTE2020 would have significantly changed the election result.

Whoever is responsible for the NN election process, please return my 1M VOTE2020 asap, and I will vote immediately.

What has happened is clearly unfair to ME

I will wait 5 days, if the Komodo NN election officials don't respond in that time I will announce how I would have allocated my remaining 1M VOTE2020 here.

I think some NN candidates who narrowly missed out on getting elected in season 4 will be interested to see whether they should have been elected, had I known not to waste 1M VOTE2020 on a candidate who should have been disqualified from running in the first place.

It is understable why a voter would be upset in such case. But on the other hand and like someone pointed out on Komodo discord:
"It would also be very unfair for everyone else who voted if the voter in question was allowed to re-cast his votes.
Knowing the results that would be created by his/her vote allocation would allow for choosing results. Other voters could then also make the claim that they would have also voted diferently after seeing the 1,000,000 votes alocated differently.
This situations is very unfortunate."

And I would add that voters should be aware of the risks involved when voting for totally anonymous candidates and in that case a candidate who came at the last minute pretending without any kind of evidence to be someone who disapeared since almost 4 months leaving his node down. This server is still down as of today even though wrrpt500something pretended to be back on track as blackjok3r... That candidate, also put the wrong address for his last minute proposal at the beginning. All details that should have raise concerns in the voter's mind.

Then I don't know when the details of the disqualifying action were discovered but I guess if they knew before the election they would have disqualified his proposal but only the team could explain how it happened.

Strovu

Posts

Merits