Quote from: brg444 on September 03, 2015, 05:37:35 AM

Quote from: adamstgBit on September 03, 2015, 05:33:13 AM

Quote from: BitProdigy on September 03, 2015, 04:49:34 AM

1) We don't have a clear consensus building process. We need to decide if we want 75% consensus within 1000 blocks by the miners followed by 95% consensus within 1000 Blocks, or if we just want 80% consensus within 5000 blocks. We need a clear process.

>75% of miners willing to accept the change simply lets devs know it's safe to implement.

dev's should reach consensus and use miner votes and BTC votes to help them reach consensus, would gavin had created bitcoinXT had he known <1% of miners would support it, while >60% support BIP100. i don't think he would of wasted his time. maybe he would of changed his mind and created a new BIP, but that's too late now, poor gavin cast away, forever?

75% is dangerously low...

wtv thats up to the devs to decide on any given polling

if the poll is between BIP123 or no BIP at all and we get only 75% on BIP123, i agree with you its dangerously low...

if the poll between 6 slightly different BIP 40% might be enough for devs to choose and say they have reached consensus, with ALL devs backing 1 BIP it could go from 40% to 99% pretty fast

would be fun to watch.