Post
Topic
Board India
Re: Is the guy proposing BIP 106 from India ?
by
skang
on 08/09/2015, 20:09:41 UTC
Apart from BIP 106 all of BIP 100, 101, 103, 105 are suggesting block size increase/adjustment in various ways. I dont see you going to threads discussing those BIPs and protesting so vigorously. What prompts you for your warfare against BIP 106 ? Because an Indian has done it without taking your permission ?

You are saying that everyone is saying BIP 106 is very bad. But, as I can see, BIP 106 (which was known as BIP 1xx before the formal assignment of BIP no.) is getting more vote than BIP 100 and BIP 101 - https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=1164466.0 (though I am well aware that a public vote on BitcoinTalk is not very indicative about a critical decission).

I do also think that BIP 100 will win, not because it is the best, but because pool operators are backing it, as it gives final say to them. But, why are you so furuous about the fact that the proposal of an Indian is getting acclaimed in International platform ?

Firstly, I have I have criticised all those BIPs you have mentioned. Secondly, & more importantly, Upal directly asked for my opinion & you had seen that.
Thirdly, I sensed I was being perceived that way so I backed out & refrained from commenting on last 3 occasions it was presented, after I tried to convince him personally.

Forget me and him as a person. Consider only the arguments; Is it such a bad thing that I am asking to consider the arguments?