HUH?
if its not far superior then why do it?
Your sarcasm detector has run out of fuel or has never worked in the first place. One could easily conclude from that list that SegWit is much greater of the both proposals.
Also dont see what that has to do with your comment of "we would have this same discussion very soon if growth is going to increase".
Because 2 MB blocks don't solve anything. All it does is kick the can a little bit down the road.