Quote from: Technomage on November 30, 2012, 03:55:27 PM

Quote from: casascius on November 30, 2012, 03:49:03 PM

I don't think kicking someone off an internet chat channel is actively reducing the possibility of Iran use of Bitcoin.

Based on his comments before the ban he is very much against talking about it at all. There are many other public venues of talking about it and I think this thread and the coverage it currently has in Reddit is actually much more public than a darn IRC channel. What he did gave it 100 times more publicity than it would've got if there was just a discussion in an IRC channel.

Not surprising: I would expect he is against talking about it. The media would salivate over even a 10-second sound bite of a "core Bitcoin developer in the US" talking about subverting the policies of the US government. He seems like a smart guy. I don't blame him.

Quote from: Technomage on November 30, 2012, 03:55:27 PM

I also wanted to comment on the Silk Road comment that you removed and I'll just say that I think the policies regarding talk about Silk Road are ridiculous as well. Silk Road is an anonymous marketplace by definition. Talking about it, using it, does NOT imply illegal activities. Silk Road itself is NOT illegal. I have actually consulted this with a lawyer because we've run into users in our service that talk to us about Silk Road. As long as the user doesn't mention drugs or other illegal substances, we have no problem providing service to people who mention Silk Road.

You are not in the same position as him. His name is on the front page of Bitcoin.org as a developer and yours is not. His personal freedom is put at risk by being willing to discuss these topics on the record, yours is not.