because a hard fork is not just one thing. its people like you who unconvincingly try to brush stuff under the rug and treat it all as a disaster.
controversial vs consensus
accidental vs intentional.
So after a redundant analogy, you resort to ad hominem?
Oh please, every damn sentence on this forum is an ad hominem to you. Every time you discuss larger blocksizes, you say 2mb would be a disaster and discard any notions to the contrary. It's neither an insult nor a personal attack to accurately describe the behaviour you demonstrate on a frequent basis.
The fork debate has been beaten to death, and you've provided no good reasoning for it.
I've heard more valid points from him than I have from you.