If you guys are working for your lists to be adopted by everyone (you seem to be going for this) then i dont think its smart for a small group of like minded individuals to act as judge, jury and executioner. Just my 2 cents tho, good luck on your project
Valid, yet unbased concerns. People do not end up on these lists because they are innocent. Besides, there is a review process (i.e. we give people a second chance) in addition to this:
2) Review members that you come across (from the blacklist) yourself.
In other words, if one is concerned with the integrity of the list and they want to use it, then
it is their responsibility to review members. Besides, we can't force people to adopt the list.