Trying to be mostly neutral and searching for a unifying solution, I see SW supporters running out of convincing arguments and try hiding behind polemic and insult not only here but even in most SW loving forum there is lot of confusion

https://np.reddit.com/r/Bitcoin/comments/5ukz58/segwit_is_a_softfork_to_miners_without_supporting/

+ all efforts to claim SW is THE no brainer solution and needs to be just waived through because core knows better and is fully tested and disclaimer free

+ seeing BU expands adoption (despite not 'fully' tested), SW stalls:

One can only conclude, so far, SW is Not the no brainer and needs either  to be entirely reviewed or abandoned.