Quote from: jtwalker42 on November 05, 2017, 04:43:49 PM

Quote from: blockchainvault on November 05, 2017, 03:36:35 PM

Thank you for this comprehensive comparison!!! I was actually wondering about this myself. It seems there are many ICOs these days that have the same basic idea, though the devil is in the details on which ones are superior.

It depends on what you mean by superior. Why are we using decentralized anonymous markets in the first place? Privacy. Unfortunately none of the coins on the graph offer that. If you check the graph you'll notice none of them use the ring signature method. Why is that? Can they really claim to keep our transactions private?

Privacy is not the only reason to use a decentralised market place especially a double deposit escrow one.

It is an essential part of end to end trustless enviroment we are all trying to build.

Just as decentralised exchange is.

The only trustless one is bitbay here. The others are not trustless. You will need to trust mods and arbiters.

HOWEVER

Sys is another very good project too that dev is certainly a top level developer and both bitbay and sys have some of the best minds here behind them.

Both are below value but to me bay is further below real value at this point since sys has a 5 x bay cap right now.

I don;t think we should be saying one is better than the other here ...all of these projects have strong teams behind them actually. I personally would say bay and sys are ahead.

All 3 here are way better than 90% of the other projects here in that they have their own strong conceptual designers/coders of a high level.

Get some of all of them if you wish i dont think the thread should be causing any issue between these teams.

I have a chunk of each of them I can disclose i have more bay that sys and more sys that particl

Simply because at their current values that is what i personally believe is the smart move. If not I would change that around. You can study their designs and make up your own minds of course as is always best.

If you cant decide pick up a little of each i guess or just move on an look at other interesting projects with proven developers and functioning software with real use cases.