Quote from: mnyonpa on August 06, 2013, 11:33:10 AM

Quote from: cygnusxi on May 10, 2013, 03:00:12 AM

Protein folding will not effect the blockchain. hashers will secure the blockchain (confirm in previous post). Hashers will be sharing a portion measured by bench marking hardware of similar value.

If folding is separate from mining, it means that half of the network will effectively run the Folding@home client while the other half will waste their GPU power mining the coin. What the point of the coin, then? Wouldnt it be better just to assign some reward in established cryptocurrency like Bitcoin, mine it and then give rewards to those who contribute to Folding@home? Or at list make your coin merged minable with Bitcoin, like Devcoin and Namecoin had done. Or with LTC if you want scrypt.

In order to make a coin that will do something useful, the useful algorithm should at the same time ensure the security of the blockchain. So far, this was only done as a proof of concept by Primecoin, because finding prime chains is doubtfully useful. Only this way the hashing power is not a simple waste of energy.

What you so far propose is to waste energy in order to create some doubtful (because the coin will not magically gain value) economic incentive for participating in Folding@home. Does not sound very convincing.

These systems distributed projects already work by rewarding users with "credits" (useless, it is more like scores) for contributing the network.
Of course it is a nice thought to think that it would be neat if these "credits" actually had a monetary value.
But maybe, NOT having a monetary value is more effective in these altruistic projects (as I explained before in page 5).

Now, in a similar light we have a analogue case of monetarily incentivized coinchat.org vs. normal non-incentivized IRC chatrooms.
It will be interesting to see if coinchat actually flourishes or crashes and burns. Something that boosts the extrinsic motivator in coinchat.org is the randomness of the incentives which may cause "addiction" to its users, so it is an interesting live social experiment.