Quote from: Kavallo on January 26, 2018, 06:31:22 PM

Quote from: QuestionAuthority on January 26, 2018, 06:07:19 PM

Quote from: Kavallo on January 26, 2018, 05:52:39 PM

Quote from: QuestionAuthority on January 26, 2018, 05:08:16 PM

Quote from: Kavallo on January 26, 2018, 04:55:51 PM

Quote from: QuestionAuthority on January 25, 2018, 05:18:58 PM

Just like with beggars on the street, I would be willing to give to a beggar thats creative. I would give this guy $10.

Of course, a creative beggar is providing a service which should be rewarded. However, I'm afraid 10$ would solve only a few micron of that beggar's problem

So should we open a CREATIVE MERIT BEGGING thread? Wink

That would open the way to a whole new ecology of merit-rewarding games and competitions, even though I am afraid that the true spirit of the reform could get *slightly* twisted in the process...

Thats probably the most positive thing someone has said in this thread yet. It would be interesting to see an off-topic thread devoted to games and competitions that paid in merit. Creative begging could pull beggars from other sections of the forum and let them go nuts in off-topic without being banned. LOL

I'm happy you've appreciated it.
But if this is allegedly "the most positive thing someone has said in this thread yet", why did I not receive any single merit by anyone? I'm afraid that begging will really become a much better way of receiving merits than just doing your good sincere posts. That's because there are so many form of begging - direct ones, indirect ones, implicit ones, suggested ones, and I won't mention butt-licking - hooops... I did it. It's true that this new merit criteria will probably slow down spam, but in the best case scenario it will also push most people who are not legendary yet to conformism and thus to express only opinions which are likely to get rewarded with merit.

Maybe, but there are people that dont like conformity and will give you merit. I think like minded people will support each other by giving each other merit. Thats the same problem the Reddit karma system has. It doesnt foster good debates it forms cliques. Ive seen groups of the same people move into a thread on reddit and crush someone that has a different view from their own. This system may actually curtail spam and abuse or it may force people into little groups that form into larger beasts by increasing the like minded membership in their clique. Only time will tell.

I have never liked the human attitude of forming "cliques" for whatever reason. I find it somehow a quite sub-human feature, a heritage of the cavemen we've been for hundreds of thousands of years and that in many cases we still are, alas. I had hoped to be able to escape that stuff online in general and on Bitcointalk in particular, but it seems that one way or another wherever you go you always end up surrounded by people aggregating in cliques hostile to each others ...

Im hoping (and helping) it will not become that way.