Well, to be honest here I don't think theymos can please everyone.

I remember that we got a lot of requests for Matthew to be banned after the Pirate event too. I guess if we went for the all-ban policy for scammers Matthew wouldn't be around to amend his bet by repaying partially here...
Agreed, but this was a year ago, and is completely irrelevant, here.
He was banned for
trolling.
Not because he screwed up earlier - which everyone, including him, agrees upon.
Not because people asked theymos to ban him in mp (hopefully).
Just because of... trolling.