Quote from: monkeydominicorobin on February 12, 2018, 01:44:37 AM

Quote from: LtMotioN on January 23, 2018, 09:58:18 AM

Hi Forum
Hoping you can educate me a bit here. I wasn't heavily into crypto at the time this all took place.
When the whole scaling debates began basically two solutions were proposed, which as we know lead to the creation of BCH.
Why did we not move BTC to 2MB blocks while work on the layer 2 scaling was being finalized? As I understand LN right now when a channel is closed the transactions in it get processed by the main chain, thus a bit of extra blocksize would help scale LN even more.

To me, I personally like the idea of layer 2 scaling more because of all the features it would add to BTC and new things it would make possible. I see some merit in both solutions though.

Is there a good reason apart from politics that we couldn't have just done both? It would have carried us for now until new scaling solutions are done and fully tested.

The BTC vs BCH has really split the community, yea there's some funny memes around this and all, but its not good that we are all fighting each other and getting super opinionated around this. I hope we don't see more separation in the community in the future.

P.S. lets not turn this into a BTC vs BCH argument here, make love not war

The scaling itself is about politics. Making laymen believe in scaling itself is politics. Increasing the block size unnecessarily will only clog the whole system. No one should care about scaling since it is the job of the developers. If you are not into programming you might as well shut up.

I would argue with that on an ideology standpoint. Bitcoin has no leader so that means everyone who is part of the network from a miner to a node to just a guy holding some BTC should be involved in the environment and cast their vote by buying or selling or moving hashing power.

Since writing this I found that with segwitt we already have 2Mb blocks, Coinbase will be implementing it soon. I think we are going to do well on scaling once that happens.
It is still a pity that this whole separation came to be in the community.