Quote from: The Pharmacist on March 26, 2018, 04:42:49 AM

Quote from: whistleblower2 on March 26, 2018, 03:39:50 AM

This type of activity is either an indication that someone is a scammer, or it isn't. There really is not a lot of gritty area here.

That isn't true, not by a long shot. The gray area is the whole reason why scammers aren't banned and DT members have to take care of them with feedback.

I have indeed removed feedback from users when they've proven themselves to be good members of bitcointalk. It's rare, but it's happened. I consider people who deal in bitcointalk accounts to be guilty until they prove themselves otherwise. My thought is that when you are buying an account, you're either going to use it for its reputation to scam, or you're going to use it for its rank to get into a campaign--probably to shitpost with. Either use is pretty sketchy. But people have earned positive trust and have proven themselves to NOT be shitposters eventually, and I am willing to give second chances in those instances.

Quote from: whistleblower2 on March 26, 2018, 02:50:22 AM

Ignoring concerns is not okay.

You don't understand what we're dealing with here. My inbox is not filled with rational arguments for feedback removal, which I certainly would consider. It is filled with stuff like the following:

Quote from: sarmrakib on January 19, 2018, 08:49:43 AM

Dear Sir,
I m a poor person. I m suffering my life with the earning of btalk. After few days later my moms eye operation I need money either she will blind.Its only my earning way. Please boss forgive me if I did any wrong. And remove my red trust. Its only my one account I do not use any account more. Please sir help the poor god will help u.

Quote from: sarmrakib on January 19, 2018, 09:03:23 AM

Dear Sir
I know you are good person. I will die sir if my mother will blind. Plz help me sir I will follow what you say I never do mistake more. Plz boss save my life. I m bagging you!!!

Quote from: Shaour Zafar094 on January 19, 2018, 09:30:13 AM

Dear manager
I hope you are doing good.
It is my humble request again, please give me one more chance to improve my post and knowlwde and i'll try make quality post, please reconsider your decision of negative trust that you have given me and please give me a second chance.English is not my first language so i am not so good at english. please re consider your decision and give me one more chance to improve myself..
If you find me in future doing low quality post you can BAN my account but please give me a second chance.

Regards: Shaour Zafar094

^^Note that I'm not a manager of anything.

Quote from: sunilnagaraja1996 on January 19, 2018, 09:32:29 AM

Tell me reason bledy fuck you stupid fellow you have sense tell me currect reason

Quote from: Sangkuni on January 19, 2018, 09:34:52 AM

sir pls, im sorry Sad

Quote from: Jraf95 on January 19, 2018, 09:59:36 AM

Hi good eve.

I would like to apologize what I've did, I'm just a new beginner and I dont know that it's not allowed to qoute legendary people.

I'm begging, I want my account clear with no problem by others.
Can i have you're trust again sir?

Best regards,
Jraf95

Quote from: Ther3dh4t on January 19, 2018, 12:04:41 PM

Hi sir, please can you remove the negative trust on me, that post was very long ago when i was a newbie.
Please give some little consideration. Thanks

^^Note that the "very long ago" part is referring to my feedback being left 2 months prior.

Quote from: Sangkuni on January 19, 2018, 12:16:47 PM

sir, can u review again why u give me redtrust.... and what do u mean about "3 world shitposters" ?

Quote from: Ma Nancy on January 19, 2018, 02:20:28 PM

hello sir, im newbie in bitcointalk ,please remove my red trust because this the only way i earn money, promise i did not do it again. .

Quote from: Rubick99 on January 19, 2018, 02:23:44 PM

Hi sir, I'm sorry before. I will ask to you how to erase my DT-2 and negative trust? Can you help me, please. I hope you read this message and help. Thanks

And on and on...hopefully you get the picture. What I'm getting is begging, and these people can barely do this coherently.

If someone really has a strong argument that I've left feedback in error, they can start up a thread and some community feedback wouldn't hurt. But if I don't block them? They will flood my inbox with this gibberish, and there are just too many for me to allow that.

And who is it you think I need to defend my position on each and every feedback to? If the people in the trust hierarchy think I'm getting it all wrong, they will cast their collective vote and I'll no longer be on DT--it happened before and it could well happen again. I accept that. But in the meantime, I think I'm doing a reasonably good job tagging the ones who need to be tagged.

Quote from: whistleblower2 on March 26, 2018, 02:50:22 AM

why have you not left Lauda, mexxer-2, or yahoo62278 a Red Tag?

Because they haven't earned my distrust. Lauda & Yahoo62278 definitely have earned my trust, mexxer-2 much less so. I'd probably leave mexxer-2 a negative for scamming Lutpin if I thought it would make a difference, but it wouldn't. I'm leaving that entire matter to Lutpin and Lauda, who have already negged him and know far more about what happened or didn't happen than I do.

Are you crazy "The Pharmist" ? Do you think all these people are begging to you to that they will die if you wont remove negative trust ?
Or they will stave to death ? or their near ones are in trouble ?

You miss the whole point here. All of them are trying to warn you that you will face all these probelms in your life soon if you keep on doing the evil things with innocent people.

Feeling so sad for you, Pharmist Grin