Quote from: micax1 on April 30, 2018, 06:40:58 AM

Quote from: doktor83 on April 30, 2018, 06:31:46 AM

target_fan_speed in RPM should be only added to gpu_config section only, per card basis?
Yes

target_temperature should work in general section by design?
If you omit the setting on top of config, it assumes it's not set.
If you set it > 0 , it will use it for every card available.
If you set it to 0, or omit it completely, and put it in gpu_conf section for each card, then it will use those settings.

Why i made it like this ?
By setting target temp on top, every card will adjust it's fanspeed to maintain this temperature.
Target fan speed isn't supported in general section cause it's something that is let's say unique for every card.
Fan speed 3000 may hold one card on 45c , other on 60.

well not in case you have rx 550 rigs.. that have 12 cards each. but that`s ok, % is more reliable for general case, i can agree.

Quote from: doktor83 on April 30, 2018, 06:31:46 AM

It does, but i don't know how it should work if you set one thing with 3rd party tool, one in miner. You set fans on 75%, but want temperature 55c.
So do you want 55c or 75% fan speed ?

if only miner can control fans out-of the-box with target temperature, I turn off all third party tools, and enjoy easy deploy and config.
however its not the case (

Thats waht i get with only miner control of fans:
(temps above 70 are devastating for these cards - and they hit it pretty quick)

Quote from: micax1 on April 29, 2018, 02:50:30 PM

Code:

[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU0: 465.0 H/S [T: 52c, RPM: 0, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU1: 435.0 H/S [T: 62c, RPM: 904, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1800 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU2: 499.0 H/S [T: 60c, RPM: 860, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU3: 499.0 H/S [T: 59c, RPM: 813, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU4: 460.0 H/S [T: 60c, RPM: 870, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU5: 449.0 H/S [T: 53c, RPM: 0, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU6: 397.0 H/S [T: 61c, RPM: 863, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU7: 437.0 H/S [T: 62c, RPM: 815, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU8: 496.0 H/S [T: 59c, RPM: 0, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU9: 492.0 H/S [T: 61c, RPM: 1061, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU10: 452.0 H/S [T: 52c, RPM: 0, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]
[2018-04-29 17:41:59] GPU11: 499.0 H/S [T: 62c, RPM: 924, CC: 1150 MHz, MC: 1900 MHz]

You can always set fan speed, if temperature_target isn't working for you.
For ex you know the RPM you need, you can set it in gpu_conf.