Quote from: pgmforever on October 31, 2018, 02:34:24 PM

1) why it worked in the first place, doesn't the scriptPubKey go via the same validation rules as the scriptSig ?

Because the scriptPubKey is only half of a script. It cannot be executed. If it were, it would always fail because a scriptPubKey is just part of a script. Same with the scriptSig; it is just part of a script. On their own, neither can be executed and get a successful result.

Quote from: pgmforever on October 31, 2018, 02:34:24 PM

2) why would bitcoind even care about the scriptPubKey of the UTXO i'm trying to spend, i thought it was supposed to just first run then keep the stack and run (which it may already consider valid...?)

The scriptPubKey defines the spending conditions, i.e. what needs to go into the scriptSig. It has to run the scriptPubKey to ensure that the scriptSig is correct.

You can think of the scriptSig being the first half of a script and the scriptPubKey being the second half. On their own, they mean nothing and when executed on their own, they will fail. But concatenate them together, and you get a full script which can be executed. That is conceptually what script validation does. Before script validation, neither the scriptPubKey nor the scriptSig are considered valid.

The scriptPubKey in an output can be anything, it is not and cannot be validated when it is created. There have been multiple instances of people putting random garbage in scriptPubKeys. Those transactions are totally valid and in the blockchain. It is just that the outputs are not spendable because attempting to spend them would result in an invalid script.