Quote from: sanders.334 on February 04, 2014, 04:45:05 AM

FlipPro,
Firstly, thank you for bringing some order to this nightmare...

Here's my proposal. We have 45 designers, and let's say we each get 1 vote. The problem is we all have an urge to vote for ourselves, which would result in 1 vote for each person. We need to have several rounds of voting, and no one can vote for themselves until the last round (or last two rounds, for example).

For example:

45 designers total:

1st round: each designer vote for 5 other designers (can't vote for yourself)
then select the top 10 designers with most votes

2nd round: each designer (all 45) vote for 3 of the remaining 10 designers.
select the top 5 designers with most votes

3rd round: each designer (all 45) vote for 2 of the remaining 5.
select top 2 designers.

Final Round: each designer (all 45) vote for 1 of the remain 2 logos.

I feel it's safest we all just write the names in, so we know there is no cheating. For example:
round 1...I vote for:
1. Freddy
2. Tammy
3. Sally
4. Jimmy
5. Frank

Also, I doubt all 45 designers will vote, so make sure people aren't cheating by creating an account and masquerading as one of the absent designers. I've noticed a few people on this forum are very talented at creating sock puppets - it's pathetic, really.

Also, no more petitioning, "vote for me". Each person, look at the google doc and select 5 names, then 3 names, etc.

This is my general concept, feel free to modify the number of rounds or the number of votes, etc. if you please.

Again, FlipPro, thank you for stepping-in...I was really starting to lose hope in homo-sapiens in general.

sanders334

that seems fair to me^^