I just hope JusticeforYou can find an old usb drive with the backup for the lost private keys. I'm not sure what to think of the red tag. 
-snip-
The only reason for which he was not tagged sooner is his rank. Had it been a normal member they would long have been red (all the prior discussed things considered). -snip-
-snip-
However, I'm not certain IP addresses from years ago mean much since many carriers have dynamic IPs.
Correct; it could be the same area though. However, JusticeForYou could simply claim they moved and thus (conveniently, again) aren't in the same area anymore.However, I'm not certain IP addresses from years ago mean much since many carriers have dynamic IPs.
People use their own IP to login on this board?
If you can not find wifi left open in a built up area or be bothered with tor the minimum would be a throw away phone.
I feel the onus should be on the accuser to prove it is not the same person. What happens to innocent until proven guilty.
Neutral trust is the max here else it can be seen as very very heavy handed.