Making an infographic like this makes it look official, which it's not. If I'm not mistaken, we're still having a discussion about what's acceptable and what's not as far as leaving trust, and I disagree with a couple of the ones on this, like not giving negs for certain rule violations like harassment. Plus the "unless on rare occasions" qualifier sort of makes that suggestion near meaningless. I also don't agree that negs should be left for merit issues unless it's particularly egregious and even then it's a judgement call I don't think Theymos approves of.
All in all, this is premature. You probably want to help and likely are looking for merits, but an infographic of this stuff isn't needed right now. Just my opinion.
I agree with The Pharmacist that the discussion is still ongoing about what is acceptable and what is not.
However it is good that others like yourself are taking an interest in this discussion and bringing the community together to create some agreement about trust.
With this it is important to listen to all sides of the debate. People that have different opinions often have some very valid contributions.
I'd like to add to this topic: before leaving feedback, ask yourself if your feedback makes the forum better, and (if applicable) is it worth destroying someone's reputation?
You should be able to explain why this is true:
Negative - You were scammed or you strongly believe that this person is a scammer.
Mdayonliner also has a good
discussion thread about this.