Taking away satoshi's coins is no different than what happened with ETH&DAO in the past. Immutability is bitcoin's core feature. If you take away satoshi's coins and redistribute them, you'll just fork yourself away into another shitcoin which nobody uses.
So... did immutability win in the case of ETH&DAO?
Ethereum did the right thing and people agreed to it, see the current situation of Ethereum Classic for proof. Immutability didn't succeed!If you take away satoshi's coins and redistribute them, you'll just fork yourself away into another shitcoin which nobody uses.
If a group of person can decide to take one person's stash and redistribute them, then they can decide to take mine later too.
Contradiction detected