Quote from: gentlemand on February 13, 2019, 04:20:13 PM

If the one particular person who initiates a dump to 3k doesn't do it, someone else would've been along at some point to fulfill that destiny

I see what you mean

And this is where we disagree. In short, you assume that there is some form of price destiny (like where price "organically" belongs). I say that the whole thing is meaningless like when someone moves the price down and it stays there (with the rest completely inconsequential). Then someone else moves it up and it remains there all over again. In this way, the whole market may be indifferent as to where the price currently is or might be. So there is no "destiny" as it all comes down to someone moving the price hither and thither

To put it differently, the price can be both dead and alive, organic and arbitrary