Your explaination about your personal bheviours looks decent to me, I don't think you did something wrong in giving merits to the banned users as it is not displayed clearly on the forum. But there is no explanation about smartman being trustworthy in any sense, if you see he has clearly tried to spam the forum by offering this services.
REQUIRED POSTING IN ENGLISH THREADS
1. Contact me if in your accounts at least half of the posts in English.
2. Posts up from 100 signs.
3. Express an opinion about the project, ask questions. Don't write nonsense.
4. English is not Google translate.
5. You have from 5 accounts.
Is this something thats allowed here ?
I don't like point number 5. But I need proof that it was used and how it was used. Without this data, I can not draw conclusions in this case. I wrote about this in detail for one DT1 member.
https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5105163.msg51458554#msg51458554Item number 3. It depends on the nature of the content. If there is no spam, plagiarism, deception, this is not a violation. They can be project participants, testing it and asking questions. I can not be sure of this and can not prove otherwise.
The issue of having multiple accounts has been discussed in the Russian section many times. You need to know how these accounts are obtained and how they are used. I was surprised to learn that the user does not receive a negative trust due to the participation of several accounts in different bounty. I asked DT members if its enough for a negative trust, user interest in buying or selling an account, or for his loyalty to it? We discussed for a long time, I heard a lot of opinions that to destroy trust based only on this is not correct. Therefore, in this case, if the user claims that his service was used constructively, I will not be able to refute.
If I interrupt my interaction with users on the basis of suspicion or demand crystal clear purity, I can lose most of the useful content. In life it happens, it seems that I am 100% sure, and then it turns out that I was mistaken. Need proof. How many spam reports did this service receive? No answer. Deadlock ...