Quote from: Tytanowy Janusz on September 18, 2019, 06:14:35 AM

Quote from: webtricksALT on September 18, 2019, 04:37:27 AM

Except for the fact that I wasn't giving away some new fancy shitty altcoin. My giveaway was in well-established altcoin which is currently having market cap of 318M. I know people abuse giveaways through their newly created tokens but giveaway in listed top 50 cryptocurrency is as good as bitcoin giveaway.
Also if people are allowed to giveaway physical coins and even Lamborghini in games and round section, what harm dogecoin is doing to attract 30 days ban.

There is not even a single word about token marketcap or token place on the CMC list in theymos post quoted by PrimeNumber7.

I know there is not a single word about marketcap in rules. But I was just implying that it's a kind of dumb to cover all altcoins in this definition when real abuse was due to giveaways launched by ICO coins.

Quote

Quote from: webtricksALT on September 18, 2019, 04:01:46 AM

That's the reason why 'Games and Round' section exists, isn't it?

Games and rounds section is made to host games (pick number etc). Giveaway thread that requires users to post usernames is not a game.

Giveaway is pretty common in Games and Round section. I'm not the first one to create giveaway thread.

Quote from: rhomelmabini on September 18, 2019, 09:13:22 AM

Even though that isn't a shitcoin the rule is as clear as crystal that users are just replying insubstantial posts on your thread. I guess it's not just you who have been banned but the people as well that posted their usernames on your thread, that's kind of sad, may it be an eye opener to everyone that rules do run here.

So you saying, my one page thread contained more insubstantial posts than this 78 pages holy thread: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=5138787.0 !! Just because he is giving away money in Bitcoin, he should be allowed to create the thread containing 1550 insubstantial posts and counting?
I was giving away in dogecoin (a coin having market value just like Bitcoin), not some shitty self-created ICO/Airdrop coin.

I still think 30 days ban is kinda harsh on me. I know I broke rule due to the complexity of rules but 7 or 14 days would been a more appropriate in my case. I have thread to maintain, since I can't reply to people's queries anymore on forum it's lose-lose for both me and forum members having genuine concerns.