Quote from: LoyceV on Today at 04:48:33 PM

When in doubt, you can try reporting it again.[/url]

Thx for the suggestion! I was wondering if this report can be changed from Bad to Good though, without making another report... and risking having that one flagged as bad also.

Quote from: LoyceV on Today at 04:48:33 PM

On second thought:

Quote from: GazetaBitcoin on Today at 04:40:07 PM

I reported this post as it does not the rule stated in OP:

I don't think not following the exact format makes it off-topic. If OP wanted that, he could have made the thread self-moderated.

Uhm... But I didn't report the post for being off-topic. I reported it for "Breaking rule stated in OP. (meaning not respecting the posting format rule from the OP; and this is the same reference I wrote for all other good reports on this topic).

Quote from: LoyceV on Today at 04:48:33 PM

If OP wanted that, he could have made the thread self-moderated.

I discussed with topic's author prior stating the new rule in the OP if we should create a new topic from scratch, self-moderated, or if we should keep this one and report all posts not respecting the rule. And we decided to keep this topic, as it has already a history, it contains many suggested movies and many users know the topic already... That's why we kept this topic instead of creating a new, self-moderated one.

Quote from: LoyceV on Today at 04:48:33 PM

I'd let it go, then again, I barely visit the Off-topic board anyway.

Most likely I'll do the same... But if a mod would be kind enough to pop in the conversation and explain the situation, it would be great. I'm just curious, that's all...

Quote from: Csmiami on Today at 04:54:36 PM

The only thing I see missing from the local rule is the genre; so maybe the mod handling the report deemed it not to be such a big thing. Even if the link is embedded in the text instead of in a separate space

Well, this is why rules exist: to be respected... Now if this post remains there and my report remains bad, this would create a precedent for others which would avoid posting in the stated rule, right?

Quote from: Rikafip on Today at 05:00:11 PM

Thing is, @GazetaBitcoin stated that he previously reported similar posts that were not following the format, and all those posts were deleted so far. That's why he assumed this was a mistake, not deleting it even though it obviously doesn't follow the format.

Yes, this is what I meant.

Quote from: Rikafip on Today at 05:00:11 PM

I reported the post too, lets see what happens.

Thx, Rikafip!

Quote from: Rikafip on Today at 05:00:11 PM

Imho, since Movie thread is in Off-Topic board which attracts spammers, more elegant solution would be to open new self-moderated thread

Indeed... But, as I explained above, the topic has some history already and we thought it would be nice to keep it, if we report the posts not following the format and, of course, if the mods collaborate with us, as they did until now...