Banned permanently?  Absolutely not.  But a temp ban given as a warning or simply because the rules ought to be applied fairly to all members?  Yes, if the standard punishment is indeed a temp ban for members who keep moving threads back to where the mods don't want them--and honestly, I'm not certain if that's true.

I'm not implying or stating outright that nutildah should get banned for good, because I think he's an extremely valuable member of the forum.  It's unfortunate that this escalated to where it did.

Man, I hope he thinks twice about that.  It appears to be a decision on his part based entirely on emotion, and somehow that seems out of character for him.  There's no reason to get so upset over something like this that you leave the forum completely.  Lots of members have gotten temp bans or other sanctions, and it shouldn't be taken personally if the rules are being enforced fairly.

C'mon back, nutildah!  Nobody wants you gone.  No harm, no foul--quiet your mind down and come on back.