Quote from: Hispo on September 21, 2022, 08:30:23 PM

This is my personal review which I was accepted to perform as part of this review campaign. These are my honest comments about this projects, which have not been influenced by any other ones in this thread.
<snip>

WOW! Congratulations Hispo, great review.

---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

MY REVIEW

I tested the platform myself yesterday but I have let a few hours pass in order to think about how to explain the experience my way.

This is the very first time that I have used a testnet in Metamask, and I have to say that it was easier than I expected, thanks to the OPs instructions and this info in Medium (especially about the faucet).

Buyer: 0x6A9Fd14bbCB198f2C9A0adD80d35Fa69ea82b7A1
Seller: 0x375Cb034463B98E64fb311561CB005A1EbBE6DA6

I created three contracts in order to test all the features. Well, to be honest, in the first one I mistakenly chose DAI instead of BUSD, because DAI is the option that appears by default, and this is something I would suggest you to change because it is not the most popular stablecoin.

The UI is clean and I like it. It reminds me of the good old MEW layout (not the new one). In that sense, nothing to add: avoid adding visual noise and maintain it so that users can focus on the important data. Light blue for background evoques tranquility, generosity and protection, which are very correct feelings in the context of an escrow.

I also like the way the chat is easily accessible by switching the tab, and the red dot for notifications, like in an App. Messages appeared instantly in the counterpart's display, enabling direct communication:

And the same could be said in the way the agent is integrated in the conversation during a dispute:

Finally, the review box is also clean and I like it. To suggest something, I would also add the average stars of the reviewer, or some kind of information to assess his credibility at a glance.

Final score: 8 out of 10. This is the first escrow platform that I know and I have to say that I really liked it: easy and fast to use, and the 1% fee is the standard in the traditional escrow market afaik, so it is fair (it would be great if high traffic allowed lower fees some day). It is very likely that I will use it for some of my future business. Keep up the good work, Zenland!