I can't vote in your poll because neither option is applicable, in my opinion. I think he's honest, but not necessarily objective enough to be on DT, and last I checked he is not. And clearly I believe the second option is objectively wrong.
I'm always trying to give someone the benefit of doubt but it's really hard to do this for Timelord2067.
I gave him the benefit of the doubt for a very long time, until I couldn't watch it anymore and excluded him. He just takes things far too personal somehow, and (still) uses the feedback system as his personal diary.