Quote from: FP91G on September 01, 2023, 05:41:05 PM

Quote from: DaveF on August 30, 2023, 10:15:57 PM

Quote from: neutraLTC on August 26, 2023, 09:43:08 AM

it is concerning. many are concerned

Who are these many?

Pools have come close to if not gone over 50% in the past. And large groups of miners left them and went elsewhere. When pooled mining first became a thing there were only a couple of major pools and everyone else was still solo mining. It's not a real concern for people who understand that everything is always going to be in flux with this.

The real major concern, which is still not a real concern, would be who controls the miners that are mining at these pools.
If some government wanted to take over Bitcoin mining they could over a period of years acquire well over 50% of the hash rate. But if they took part of the hash rate and pointed it to one pool another part to another pool and so on, nobody would ever know about it until all the sudden they pointed it at their own pool. But due to the power requirements which are beyond immense and the cost of the hardware which is also beyond immense it's not a real concern for anybody who is not a paranoid nut job.

-Dave

I disagree with you, because there are not many countries in the world that can make more than 50% of the miners move to this country. These are the USA, Russia and China.
Kazakhstan also wanted to become a leader in mining, but their energy systems could not withstand such loads. China has no plans to allow bitcoin mining again.

1) Pools are not miners. I am a miner, i am US based, I do not have to mine at a US pool or any particular pool.

2) The commercial miners that have their own large farms know #1. They know that past a certain point their hashrate has to be a bit distributed.
2a) Having nothing to do with going over 50% just as a safety in case something goes wrong with pool #1

3) There are a lot of places that can support the power demands mining easily. If it can be done profitably with the current price of BTC and the other associated costs in that country is a different point.

4) Look through the history of BTC mining. Every time someplace got to big, they had large miners leave and go someplace else.

-Dave