Quote from: hugeblack on Today at 02:30:08 PM

Foxpup did this with @LoyceV's Avatar

That's incorrect. There may be time travel involved, but:

Quote from: Foxpup on July 27, 2023, 01:09:42 AM

note that all my payments are (and always have been) completely under manual control

Quote from: Z_MBFM on Today at 02:12:21 PM

In that case how Bitcoin can provide auto renewal system where we use non-custodial wallet to hold Bitcoin.

Bitcoin is designed to be electronic cash. With cash, you can schedule payments, but you'll need some automated payment system for it.

Quote from: rat03gopoh on Today at 02:44:08 PM

The bitcoin protocol does not provide an automatic sending solution

And that's a good thing! The protocol doesn't need to do things that can be done in another way. The protocol has locktimes, you can for instance create several transactions that will only become valid in the future. Or a wallet can be coded to do exactly this, it could have a separate balance that isn't locked with a password that can be used to schedule sending funds. Even better if that's LN enabled.

Quote from: albert0bsd on Today at 03:53:02 PM

Long answer, this only can be done on the client side. This is with custom scripts and cronjobs

This could easily be implemented in a wallet, say in Electrum. The fact that it hasn't been done yet makes me think there's no demand for it: anyone who wants to schedule payments (and those are mainly businesses) has another system to process payments from their wallets.

Quote

Time-locked transactions can work, but the user needs to reserve some Utxo for that. If the Utxo is spent before the date, the time-locked transactions become useless.

Spending the funds before the locktime can be seen as a way to cancel your subscription.

Quote

the Time-locked transactions is a policy for the mempool, but not for the miners I read before that if the time-locked transactions is sent to a miner they can mined that regardless of the time-locked restriction.

When using Locktime, the transaction is not valid before it reaches a certain block (or date). No miner can change that.