Quote from: fuguebtc on Today at 05:59:28 PM

Quote from: Ryu_Ar1 on June 05, 2024, 09:55:30 PM

Being a player and being a coach are 2 different things so regardless of whatever he has gotten as a player then it will indeed be a different story if he has become a coach.

It cannot be denied that Kompany is currently in a situation that is indeed forward hit and backward also hit because however great expectations and demands for Kompany clearly have to be proven by current achievements.
When he was a player, no one doubted his ability but when he became a coach it would be very different especially with Kompany's track record which was not very good.

At present, Kompany's advantage is only that he is indeed with good resources at Bayern because even though this season Bayern lost but they are still one of the favorite clubs next season so with this advantage Kompany will get a little gap to breathe but on the other hand this is also a burden because with the current big club he is immediately demanded to give the best in his first season.

He was definitely a good player. But that does not mean he's going to be a good coach. We generally see that the midfield players become really good coaches. Just look at Zidane, Alonso etc. I am not saying he will not be able to be a good coach. I just think that he has not proved himself so far. He has finished in the relegation zone with Burnley. And suddenly he has been given such a big responsibility. I think it might prove to be too much for him to handle. Everyone expects him to bring in the Bundesliga title with Bayern Munich in the next season. It wouldn’t have been an unrealistic expectation to have. But now that we know is a great team suddenly and we also know that Dortmund is also starting to perform well, we cannot say that it is going to be easy for him. Actually, it is going to be very hard for him to win the title. He also does not have much experience with a big team. That will probably be another problem.

We even see that when he was a player, he was very good and when he became a coach, he didn't do so well. I will take 2 English legends Lampard and Gerrad as an example or further I will see Ole as another example where when they played as players and when they served as coaches it was inversely proportional so in the end this cannot be equated because after all being a player and being a coach have different tasks and of course the responsibilities are also not the same.

Having responsibility at Bayern is actually not that scary because Kompany only has to be able to improve performance with a good squad at the moment but with a lot of pressure faced it could also be a blunder in the end and this is what is worried about.
But back again as long as the decision has been made by Bayern and Kompany has agreed with all the risks that are ready to be borne then there is indeed no other way but to give his best for next season because surely the focus next season for the Bundesliga is Leverkusen and Xabi's performance so that even though Bayern are favorites they will not be too highlighted more for performance problems and can even be praised if Kompany does his job well.