Quote from: Justbillywitt on Today at 03:29:06 PM

Just give me a good reason why you think they shouldn't bring back De Gea back to Manchester United? David De Gea won't be the only player to come back to his former club, many players in the past has done that. Manchester United knows the capacity of De Gea and how important he can be for them in high profile matches, and in the premier league. De Gea is a proven goal keeper who will fit in perfectly with the premier league demands. Manchester United don't need a new trial and errors with their goal keeper. They don't have to start with another experiment at the start of next season. They tried that with Onana and it didn't work, they don't need that again in the upcoming season that all eyes will be on Amorim, to see how well he will lead the team. To me I don't see any problem in bringing that young man back to the club.

I don't know why you think bringing back De Gea is a good option for Manchester United but I don't think it will be wise to bring him back though even if he is performing well for his current team. De Gea's time at United has passed and he is not fit to play for them anymore so it is better to get a new goalkeeper if they feel Onana is not the one for them. De Gea joined just as other keepers are joining so they can still get a good keeper by scouting harder.

Quote from: EL MOHA on Today at 05:14:35 PM

Quote from: Justbillywitt on Today at 03:29:06 PM

Just give me a good reason why you think they shouldn't bring back De Gea back to Manchester United? David De Gea won't be the only player to come back to his former club, many players in the past has done that. Manchester United knows the capacity of De Gea and how important he can be for them in high profile matches, and in the premier league. De Gea is a proven goal keeper who will fit in perfectly with the premier league demands. Manchester United don't need a new trial and errors with their goal keeper. They don't have to start with another experiment at the start of next season. They tried that with Onana and it didn't work, they don't need that again in the upcoming season that all eyes will be on Amorim, to see how well he will lead the team. To me I don't see any problem in bringing that young man back to the club.

Ok let me give you good reasons, first of all let’s start with Onana was a very bad signing and Manchester United got it wrong like every other club does while replacing a player, they shouldn’t have allowed De Gea go and should have given him even a year contract to see how there replacement will fair, but it was as a mistake that can happen to just every club.

But then is it right for them to bring in David De Gea back? I will personally say No except if it is as a back up, but if they are trying to replace Onana then it should be for a very young goalkeeper that they can have for many years to come, De Gea isn’t that solution, I can still recall De Gea making numerous errors too during his time at Manchester United so he isn’t perfect as people painted him.

Most of the time it is very bad going back to your ex player because it usually back fires, Real Madrid had goalkeeper crisis after letting Casillas go but that didn’t make them go back to him, personally I think a new goalkeeper as number one will be perfect than an already aged David De Gea

Everyone was convinced that Onana will do better than De Gea when they signed him because of his performance at Inter Milan and the champions league the season before united got him. It was good to get a replacement goalkeeper but they shouldn't have let De Gea go yet just as you said to see how the new goalkeeper will adapt and that way the pressure on Onana will be less and it will help with his adaptation.

I agree with you EL MOHA, even if De Gea is brought back how long will he stay? Only for a few years and they will still need another replacement so it is better to get someone younger now and move on from all this goalkeeper issues.