Quote from: Wind_FURY on September 06, 2025, 01:40:34 PM

But who would run CoinJoin in Wasabi Wallet 1.x if he/she truly cared about privacy. Definitely he/she would run Wasabi Wallet 2.x, no?

Nobody would and nobody can because Wasabi 1.x was discontinued in 2022 and the WW1 coinjoin service provided by zkSNACKs stopped in 2023 once most liquidity went to WW 2.0.

Quote from: NotATether on Today at 06:52:14 AM

Quote from: Wind_FURY on September 06, 2025, 01:40:34 PM

Quote from: ABCbits on September 03, 2025, 09:19:14 AM

FWIW, CoinJoin on Wasabi Wallet 1.x create output with ~0.1BTC amount. If anyone make LN channel with such amount, it would stand out. I also notice they show 2 image that shows tracking/clustering visualization, but it has low resolution nobody can verify it.

But who would run CoinJoin in Wasabi Wallet 1.x if he/she truly cared about privacy. Definitely he/she would run Wasabi Wallet 2.x, no?

Plus I'm not talking about opening a direct channel to himself/herself. It's merely to use two different custodial Lightning wallets from different builders and sending a transaction to himself/herself from one wallet to the other wallet.

0.1BTC outputs with the current price seems like an awful lot of money to condense in a single output. In my opinion, having the ability to create 0.01BTC outputs would be a helpful addition, but understandably, if it's not already possible today then I don't think it will be considered for a while. Because I don't think zkSNACKs is working on a newer version of WabiSabi anytime soon.

zkSNACKs, the company that developed Wasabi, doesn't exist anymore. It closed its doors during the first quarter of 2024, since then Wasabi has been maintained by volunteers from the community. The question here is why these people are pretending to be able to track a service that doesn't even exist, for a CoinJoin technology that was obsoleted several years ago, and presenting proofs that nobody can read or verify.

Quote from: NotATether on Today at 03:22:41 PM

Quote from: ABCbits on Today at 08:27:01 AM

FWIW CoinJoin protocol on Wasabi Wallet 2.x create varied amount of output.

Quote from: https://docs.wasabiwallet.io/FAQ/FAQ-UseWasabi.html#what-are-the-equal-denominations-created-in-a-coinjoin-round

So, there are 79 denominations from 0.00005000 BTC up to 1374.38953472 BTC.

I see that the denominations are quite arbitrary:

Quote

The standard denominations are: 5000, 6561, 8192, 10000, 13122, 16384, 19683, 20000, 32768, 39366, 50000, 59049, 65536, 100000, 118098, 131072, 177147, 200000, 262144, 354294, 500000, 524288, 531441, 1000000, 1048576, 1062882, 1594323, 2000000, 2097152, 3188646, 4194304, 4782969, 5000000, 8388608, 9565938, 10000000, 14348907, 16777216, 20000000, 28697814, 33554432, 43046721, 50000000, 67108864, 86093442, 100000000, 129140163, 134217728, 200000000, 258280326, 268435456, 387420489, 500000000, 536870912, 774840978, 1000000000, 1073741824, 1162261467, 2000000000, 2147483648, 2324522934, 3486784401, 4294967296, 5000000000, 6973568802, 8589934592, 10000000000, 10460353203, 17179869184, 20000000000, 20920706406, 31381059609, 34359738368, 50000000000, 62762119218, 68719476736, 94143178827, 100000000000, 137438953472 sats.

Why are many arbitrary numbers included in the denomination sizes?

Because those denominations allow us to decompose any number with minimal or no waste, what means that Wasabi coinjoins don't generate change.