Quote from: timerland on June 14, 2014, 11:05:53 PM

Quote from: maryvale on June 14, 2014, 11:01:41 PM

Quote from: maryvale on June 14, 2014, 10:54:55 PM

Quote from: supercoindev on June 14, 2014, 10:51:05 PM

Quote from: tf2honeybadger on June 14, 2014, 08:25:10 PM

Poloniex has decided not to list SuperCoin. Here is why: https://bitcointalk.org/index.php?topic=652351

lmao, this is a complete joke, if this is done by poloniex tech staff, I feel really sorry to them Grin

Here is a reply from a forum member (timerland) to that accusation:

Quote

Is this an amateur or a 10-years-old? The max coin limits the maximum coin, but does it mean the maximum coin will be generated?? Not at all. The generated coin depends on the formula in 3functions:
- GetProofOfWorkReward()
- GetProofOfStakeReward()
and
- GetProofOfWorkBonusRewardFactor()

These functions define how many coins will be generated. Moreover, even the system generates more coins than the MAX_MONEY defined above, there will be no problem at all, go look at the code. If Poloniex tech staff is that dumb, I feel very sorry for them, it is a joke! Grin

This member stated the fact. These 3 functions determined how many coins will be generated. The MAX_MONEY is largely irrelavent. All it does (and the dAmount), is to check each transaction if this limit exceeded.

I can't believe this, it's like a circus Grin

Yes, and also you can set the upper limit to be 10000000000000000000 trillion, but only generate 15 millions, is there a problem there? someone is completely idiot.

If you want to know how many coins will be generated, look at the functions generating them, not the limit. Idiot!

Again on this MAX_MONEY, for those who does not understand the code, here is where it used:

Quote

bool CTransaction::CheckTransaction() const
{
...
if (txout.nValue > MAX_MONEY)
return DoS(100, error("CTransaction::CheckTransaction() : txout.nValue too high"));

What does it mean? It mean if this *transaction* amount exceeds the MAX_MONEY, return error.

Does it check how much money you have? Not at all. You can have 10 times MAX_MONEY in your wallet!

Does it check how many coins the system generated? Not at all.

So MAX_MONEY does not limit the system generated total coin at all!

Idoits, follow and learn... you'll never get it!

I really hope this is not the real poloniex staff, I kinda like Poloniex and used it often. If it is, then Poloniex code needs some serious review, I don't want to lose money there Grin

i lost 0.7 BTC on the Hacker event, but i donate to them...