Quote from: bulanula on February 06, 2012, 11:28:32 AM

Will this include automatic fan and gpu management like cgminer ?

What about killing mining thread on GPU that has a dead fan while I am away ?

While both of these features are really nice, there is no easy way to interface with these functions on the card through OpenCL. We can do it, and I've asked jedi95 about it. His stance on the issue is pretty much what lodcrappo said:

Quote from: lodcrappo on February 06, 2012, 08:40:02 PM

please no. don't turn phoenix into the monstrosity of some other miners. it's simplicity is it's beauty.

do one thing, and do it well.

when you throw everything possible into one program, you end up with too many compromises.

So, we're definitely not adding GPU management features to the Phoenix 2 core.

Quote from: bulanula on February 06, 2012, 11:28:32 AM

IMHO cgminer is good because of auto fan feature and support for backup pools and screw all that python BS.

Thank you !

It's important to keep in mind that cgminer and Phoenix are alternatives, not competitors. We're both on the same side here. If you like cgminer better, please, use it!

Phoenix's purpose is to do things differently for those that don't prefer the way cgminer operates. (And, Python BS? I'm assuming you mean the dependencies you have to install to get Phoenix operational, since I don't see how choice of language affects the end-user, especially when the core was written with speed in mind.)

Quote from: bulanula on February 06, 2012, 08:49:20 PM

I 100% agree and support this decision. Remember the KISS principle. If you need OC stick to AMD API thing.

Adding OC and fan management is very tempting, I must admit. A thought occurs to me: What if we renamed the "kernels" directory to "modules" or the like, and allowed non-kernel modules to be loaded into Phoenix as well? This allows a third party to easily develop a complete GPU management subsystem that integrates into Phoenix while still keeping the core slim and fast for those who prefer to do OC themselves.