Quote from: Paladin69 on September 06, 2014, 09:02:32 AM

Quote from: bitcoinwonders010 on September 06, 2014, 08:59:12 AM

Quote from: atcsecure on September 06, 2014, 01:43:56 AM

Greetings Halcyon community, I am Dan Metcalf, Developer of XC. I was invited to do the review for Halcyon coin as part of my proof of code service. Im nearly done with my review of the code and expect to release the review on Sunday.
I can assure you that the code is real, the anon is a real and working solution that likely took the developer countless hours of research and programming. The solution is far superior to any of the centralized coinjoin implementations I have seen. With that being said there is potential for a cross-block chain anonymous solution since HAL is completely decentralized and trust-less.

Since I am always excited to see additional innovation coming in to the scene, and at my core my deepest desire is to see crypto currencies adopted by the main stream. I have a vision of a decentralized world and anything that supports my vision and brings us one step closer deserves a chance to do so without being senselessly attacked.

I encourage you all to do your research in to a coin before investing as this review is focused on the code and making sure it works as stated, is secure and is not a virus/Trojan.

Dan Metcalf
ATC Secure
dmetcalf@atcsecure.com

so let me get this right, your taking this comment positively

"The solution is far superior to any of the centralized coinjoin implementations I have see"

so the function is centralized. atcsecure did not say it was decentralized so how is that a good thing

I think he just made an effort to point out how other solutions are centralized.

"The [decentralized] solution is far superior to any of the centralized coinjoin implementations I have seen."

CoinShuffle is clearly referenced in their whitepaper. I believe each wallet is its own mixer node...or something.

he did not say that though, if he meant it that way he would have compared it to other decentralized functions. it is compared to centralized functions.