Good evening! Your project seems to be quite ambitious, interesting and useful for thousands of people, wishing to invest through ICO. It seems to be unique even. Neveretheless, are there any competitors in your industry? Particulary, there exists serious enough project DolphinBi. Don't you think that you have quite enough in common?
Thanks in advance.

Hi SeanPiknick,

I could go on and on on the same level of debate you started. Fortunately, some members of btt sugest us to calm down and not to reply to different provocations. However, your post and rating on your website is beyond just a simple one-man-band estimate of our project and Notary team (by the way, we started with Pre-ICO or presale, ICO is planed for September). I was always wondering what kind of people judge the others (with the high possibility of destroying their bussines, credibility, lives etc., if they are wrong) based on quick estimate of the available information, but at the same time, they were not able to even correctly rewrite few simple informations (you were not able to find a link to my LinkedIn account, but you were able to do that for many others; you gave us 50 points rating, but still we were given scam alert –  yes, I noticed that you corrected the rating after my message to your curator who resets it to zero). Any suggestion, how should I judge your professionalism and objectivity of your post and ratings based on mistakes you did?

I do not argue about your rating. But on your website is stated: »Now it still in prototype phase. It’s means what ICO Tracker and his rating is only an idea and no more! You should not make any decisions on this rating because it’s completely subjective!« As I wrote above, such »subjective« ratings have consequences. I hope you can cope with that.

Our investors can get refunded after unsuccesful Pre-ICO which ended a few days ago (those who decided so, already got). Everything till now was transparent and it will remain so. We will continue with the project with the remaining funds or without them, only deliveries will be at different times. We made some mistakes and most likely, we will make more in the future. But we did and we will do our best to fix them. We have only one small request – please, let us allow to work and to focus on the project you estimated we do not have knowledge and competence for it. Let as allow to surprise you, whoever you are.

Last, but not least, I would like to thank our community, who support us. Kind words are welcome. It's true that harsh and unpleasant things/words make us stronger, but as humans, we can stand only a certain dose of them.

With this post I conclude the debate about our team and Notary Platform rating on https://icotracker.net/project/ntry_platform .

Sean, I wish you the best.

Regards,
      Iztok

Though I do appreciate your purpose "to make more informed investment decisions through the ICO and want to give the opportunity for all", I believe if you demand more transparency to others, then you should be as much transparent on your side. On your website I read "Who we are? We are distributed team of enthusiasts." That tells very little about yourself...
Who are the Curators? How many are there? What kind of experience and technical expertise can they show, in order to prove their ability to assess the validity of a project?
How can you ensure your judgement is free from any conflict of interest? Etc. Etc.

I know it may look like I'm playing the devil's advocate here, but I'd like to point out those considerations above are not specifically related to this Notary project, rather to your ICO Tracker in a broader sense.

I can understand users who attend on coinfest don't want photos to reveal themselves. If coinfest are just help nearby I could be attending to this events to mingle with users from bitcointalk.


You might wanna check this article http://finance.yahoo.com/news/ethbits-launches-token-crowd-sale-113000272.html It has some important information about them.

"LocalBitcoins allows users to buy bitcoins without a bank account, but we are moving into alternative currencies to cater for the growing movement into crypto."

- Pravjit Singh, Ethbits.com Director, Founder & CEO

Fran from bravenewcoin who is the principle escrow agent came on the old thread an announced it. You can contact them at the following sites www.bravenewcoin.com and www.tokenmarket.net to confirm if you wish. If there are concerns we can ask a representative from token market to also confirm it.

I dont understand why in the ICOtracker, it says that escrow in ethbits is 0. Can someone please explain it?
Thanks.

You're allowed to have your opinion, and Jon wasn't telling you not to. What concerns people is that you aren't providing a reasoning for your scores. Like, for instance we have a 0 in escrow. We signed an Escrow deal and will be having vetted third party professionals handle investors finances. After speaking with Sergey, I find it hard to believe he didn't mention this fact to you. However, you said that even after the interview your opinion hadn't changed. That's pretty strange.

Second of all, our roadmap is quite clear, and our main product where MobileGo will launch is completed. Our Mobile Store will launch before the end of the Crowdfund (like Jon said), meaning for perhaps the first time in crypto history investors don't have to wait months or even a year till after funding to see a product. They will be investing in something that has hit the market, so there's less speculation and concerns about failing to develop.

It's great that you're taking the time to review projects like MobileGo, but saying you have a team that makes decisions doesn't provide any clarity. For all anyone knows you could be making that up and you decide based on arbitrary information.

Exactly. Back up your opinion with facts. Because right now you haven't offered one fact to back up your opinion. All we know is that you had fundamental misunderstandings about the project when you did the score. If you haven't changed your opinion after having your false assumptions corrected, then that just undermines your own credibility and the credibility of your site.

For instance, you score the roadmap as a 2. This is a joke honestly. I have invested in over 15 ICOs and MobileGo has the best roadmap of any I have ever seen. The core products have been in development already for 2 years and are going to be released BEFORE the ICO ends.  Give me one example of another ICO currently coming out in the next 3 months that can say the same thing?

At this point, you probably have your feelings hurt, but your review says much more about your project than it does MobileGo.

Perhaps you should have waited to rate the ICO until you actually understood the basics of the ICO. It was obvious that you did not read the Russian whitepaper or have a basic understanding of what is being developed prior to your review. Now that Sergey has taken time out of his schedule to interview and answer all your questions, we should expect an actual accurate review score in my opinion.

After reviewing other projects on your list, I have to say I have some serious doubts about how you come to your conclusions. I am also interested in your track record to scoring ICOs. Did ones you scored high in the past actually perform well or provide results?

We need to do better as a community to do our jobs WELL. If that means owning a review site, then you should do your reviews WELL before publishing. You owe that to all people in the crypto space.

Hi

I am the third signature and team member creativechain.org

This is my signature
xpub661MyMwAqRbcGNVeKjh4ZNbFivPryHCXuLBcEoZ6AnxqPRzysmnUQi89YaVFfCDyHWHqrR92Ynr 5f7MgoccD89FCQjYL1j2Ks5kpfYqMyHv

Multi-signature addres for ICO:
3DxW7NDrpkyK3N71vtoKyVNGW8oYqnWuH2

Escrow will be responsible for verifying compliance with all milestones. Once it is confirmed, will be delivered and percentage payments will be made to creativechain.org’s team.

Milestone 1
Final TESTNET, launch MAINNET, distribution of CREAs to investors.
Media Explorer CREA 1.0 Platform, Block Explorer.
Wallet version 1.0 MAC / WIN / LINUX and Android, (Lite SPV wallet), Full API documentation.

60% Payment

Milestone 2
Platform Creativechain / Android / IOS / LINUX / MAC / WIND
Streaming and downloading of contents.
Registration of copyright licenses (copyleft /copyleft /creative commons)
Smart contracts: Smart actions, creative chains, management and design of new contracts and package licenses.
Sale and distribution of contents: Direct purchase, Creative Commons, Royalty Free, equity crowdfunding, donations.
Social network: Channels of distribution, rating systems, encrypted chat between users, public statistics, virtual wallet.
Creativecoin cash in cash out, Buy in ATMs

 http://creativechain.org/ico/ ‎

ICO ends on May 1st. The funds will be distributed on May 2nd. The proportion is 2% Escrow 98% Creativechain Project http://creativechain.org/ico/. We will add it in the post, thanks. 

I confirm that I'll be one of the escrow for this ICO.

Good luck to everyone

Я общался с SparkIt, точнее он сам мне начал писать по-поводу переводов, причём я ему просто не отвечал, но он продолжал периодически мне слать уговоры, чтобы я заново перевёл тему в соответствии с новой их темой. Так он мне 8 сообщений прислал. После чего я его вежливо послал и он успокоился.

Я посмотрел его историю сообщений на форуме (его год не было и внезапно появился), учёл его рвение как пиар-менеджера и я уверен, что он часть "бригады".

Это понятно Но вопрос был про тех, чьи голоса вещали интересную историю. Некоторые слова были чуть ли не прямые цитаты с форума, явно люди тут в темах общаются. Могли бы и поздороваться/представиться.

whats the ICO price?

А есть ли возможность с Вами проконсультироваться по теме ICO? Интересуют рекоммендации по поводу того как лучше и правильнее подготовиться к ICO.

SeanPiknick, спасибо за ссылки! Подскажите, пожалуйста, по статусу вашего сервиса, насколько там сейчас актуальная информация(все ли ico представлены)? И правильно ли указана сумма сколько собрано денег?

Я заметил одну особенность, что в проектах, которые собирают деньги не только в биткоинах, а еще в другой валюте, у вас указывается только сумма в биткоинах, но по факту проект собрал больше. Пример Incent.

Напишите как часто вы обновляете суммы? Не думали это как-то автоматизировать чтобы все в live режиме?

Будет ли какая-то сводная статистика по всем ICO, что-то типа https://blockchain.info/ru/charts ?

Очень жду запуска вашего проекта в полную силу. А пока поделитесь, пожалуста, аналогами, где видно все проходящие ICO с актуальным статусом