Quote from: redsn0w on January 06, 2015, 01:57:43 AM

Do you think your feedback is "right" ? Why don't change it to neutral as the other users done ? I think I don't deserve the negative feedback , it is this the problem.

I'm not offering more new escrow service here , and it is obviously if one want deal with me he has to check my history profile ( as all the users make to the other users before start a deal).

You're not offering them currently but have admitted you may in the future and I think it's very likely you will, and in that case the feedback is an apt warning. What he wrote seems accurate and fair:

Refused to take personal responsibility when he messed up an transaction he was handling escrow for. The situation resolved itself because of a policy exception by a forum administrator.

He may be a honest person however should not be trusted to hold funds for others nor to handle any kind of escrow.

I agree with what he said and think you're likely a decent person but you did refuse to answer certain questions which makes me question your suitability as an escrow and for that reason I wouldn't trust you as one and would advise using someone else and I think his feedback is a valuable warning to others in this case so they can take it into consideration.

Quote from: redsn0w on January 06, 2015, 02:04:15 AM

Quote from: hilariousandco on January 06, 2015, 02:00:09 AM

....
If it's justifiable and there is genuine concern, but if it isn't the feedback will very likely get brought up here and the reasoning questioned much like this thread now. If people abuse the feedback system over personal issues it usually comes back to bite them.

In this case his negative feedback is not right , as moreia told (he was involved in "first row").

How so? Just because he wasn't involved and moreia has forgiven you doesn't invalidate your mistake or the concerns that arose from it.

Quote from: redsn0w on January 06, 2015, 02:04:15 AM

Quote from: Quickseller on January 06, 2015, 02:01:50 AM

...
Yes I believe my feedback is right. You have asked me many times, and I was threatened with negative feedback to remove it. Trust me if there was a doubt that it was right I would have removed it a long time ago and admitted my mistake.

My trust rating for you is not going to stop anyone from trading with you. At the very most it would cause someone to want to use escrow while trading with you, however even the most reputable people are willing to accept escrow

edit: I personally think the people who have left neutral feedback is incorrect

I think the negative feedback was right if I went away from the run or "bad" I've lost forever the moreia's account , but this is not the case. I'm still here , and the account was recovered.

But we never got the chance to see what happened if the situation wasn't resolved by BadBear. You yourself admitted you don't know what you would have done so you could've 'run' had it not been resolved. What if you lose a 10btc deal next time? You may run then rather than have to pay it back out of your own pocket. Should the feedback be removed until this happens again to see how you will react? I don't think it should.